Madeline (Mad) Hill and her mom have run the farm in Coalfield, Tennessee, for the past twenty years since her father left. While selling fruits, vegetables, and meats to the locals and tourists was not the most exciting life, it was always safe and predictable.
That is – until Rueben arrives. Reuben (Rube) Hill claims that Mad’s father is also his father, a father who left him thirty years ago. Reuben had hired a detective to find his dads wearabouts and in the process also found three half-siblings, one of them being Mad. Rube invites Mad to join him to find their other half-siblings and, eventually (hopefully), their father as well, to find out why he left and never once reached out to them.
And so it begins, Mad packs a bag and off she goes with Rube in search of siblings she did not know who had – and a father who it becomes increasingly clear.. has a bit of a pattern.
This book was a Bookies Book Club pick for our February read, and honestly, the synopsis gives you the feel of adventure – and well, I guess I didn’t know what to expect.
While the book was interesting – everything came together a bit too easily – and therefore unrealistically. Don’t get me started on the youngest of the four….
There was enough going on to keep me reading, but in the end, it just felt like a really long car ride.
My one takeaway as I pondered this book after I closed the last page was that this was really about family – even family you did not know you had… and while yes, that car ride was long… in between the lines this motley crew was learning about each other and building something together that they didn’t have before, and that – that was kind of cool.
If it sounds like I have mixed emotions about this one – I do. It makes me think the author wanted it to be just the way I interpreted it – a long ride…. but it was making a family at the same time.
Rated: 2.75 out of 5
Read Author Before: No
Read Author Again: Maybe, it sounds like he has good titles out there
Themes: abandonment, family
Book Club Worthy – I missed this review because I was in Florida – it sounded like the average overall was 2.5 for my book club – but I would not write it off as a selection for that reason.
Topics for discussion that would be interesting, of course is family – and what in today’s world does that include? Was this book realistic? Would you ever hop in a car with someone you barely knew, even if they were a long-lost relative? What about the dad and how the book ended? What message was the author trying to get across to us as readers?
The food part of your book group could be fun – gas station treats for sure, and also grilled cheese sandwiches 🙂












