Morning Meanderings… The Gone Girl Debate Continues


Sunday already!  I have been mowing my lawn yesterday and picking apples today… listening to Liane Moriarty’s Three Wishes on audio.  It feels like fall here in Minnesota… walking the dogs this morning it is a nippy 43 degrees.  Brisk!

Books that came in the mail this week:



The Counterfeit Lady by Kate Parker (a win!)


Driving Lessons by Zoe Fishman


The Scrivener’s Tale by Fiona McIntosh


The Case Against The Supreme Court by Erwin Chemerinsky


Yup.. no audio.  Is that weird?  LOL… pretty sure there will be some this week 🙂


As for the Gone Girl topic… did you read the book?  Are you planning on seeing the movie?  In July of 2012 I read the book and it moved me to write a spoiler page for it so I could talk more about my thoughts on it.  Since the rumors of the movie began, that Spoiler Page post receives hundreds of hits a day and people still are giving there opinions on the book, the ending, etc…  I love seeing a book fuel that much discussion. 🙂  In fact that page is probably the first time in recent days, that I had to tell a commenter to clean up their act – and I think that is the first time I have even done that on any post I have written.  The controversy continues….

I for one, am curious about the movie as I usually am when books I have read become movies.  I may not always love the movie version, but I like the contrast and seeing what vision they come up with.. good, bad, or ugly.  🙂


Share with me your thoughts on Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn!  Would love to talk Gone Girl!



25 thoughts on “Morning Meanderings… The Gone Girl Debate Continues

  1. Sheila, just thought I’d let you know that the spoiler links lead to an Amazon page for the Supreme Court book. For the record, I’m not planning on reading the book or seeing the movie. I think the trailer gives the impression that it is the wife screwing with him.

  2. Feeling like a voice in the darkness, I didn’t like Gone Girl. It’s one thing to have characters change as events unfold and more information becomes available, but when the author simply hides a character’s true nature and reveals the truth as random ‘surprises,’ that’s not storytelling to me, it’s just manipulation, which anyone can do.

  3. The first book appealed to me, but because I like to read a series in order, I have number one on my TBR. I don’t think Gone Girl is up my alley so I’ll be moving away from all that.

  4. I picked up the book because I’m a huge David Fincher fan and wanted to see the source material before the movie. I loved the book for the most part – didn’t truly love the end. I can’t wait though to see how they put it together on screen.

  5. I really enjoyed this book. I need to re-read it before the movie comes out. It makes me nervous about the ending for the movie being different. It took me a long time to be ok with the ending of the book, but I finally accepted it.

  6. I don’t know anything about Gone Girl so I guess I’m totally out of the loop! Glad to see you’re getting some discussion though, that’s fun,

    I liked The Counterfeit Lady and hope you do too. And we’ve been having 40’s at night too- brr! Fall is here i guess…

  7. I absolutely loved Gone Girl – even though the characters were both not very likable. I was didn’t see the big twist coming, but looked back after and everything made sense. That’s what a good twist should be like. I also thought the ending was fitting…each one got what he/she deserved!
    I’ve heard they may change the movie ending….will be interesting.

  8. A fascinating discussion is definitely worth comment.
    There’s no doubt that that you should publish more about this subject matter,
    it might not be a taboo subject but generally people don’t
    discuss these subjects. To the next! Many thanks!!

  9. It was a little too dark for me (I’ve felt that way about other Flynn books too) BUT I though the ending totally elevated the book and when I heard that the movie may have have changed the ending it has made me not really want to see it. Plus I don’t really think the actress playing Amy can pull it off. We’ll see.

Hmmmm... what do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s