Faces On Book Covers… Like Or Dislike?

Sheila Book Journey Faces On Book Covers

Today I was at an author event where the author was discussing his book covers.  He actually had some fascinating thoughts on them (more on that in tomorrow’s post) but one thing he mentioned stood out to  me.  He has a cover with a little girl on a tricycle peddling away so you do not see her face, he said he had her riding away as when you see the face on a cover it gives you an image of what the character looks like and he feels that should be part of the reading experience; to create the character in your mind.

 

Part of the reading experience should be to create the character in your mind.

 

Ooh…. I like that.

 

I have always had a sort of dislike for covers that have a picture of the characters on them.  Why?  Because that image is now in my head as I read the book. The girl (or boy) on the cover is now who is running through the pages which is fine if it is a move cover as we already have the character defined for us by the big box… but not for the original pre-movie (or no-movie) book.

 

Faces on covers Sheila Book Journey A Crooked Number Nathan Jorgenson Vampire Academy Richelle Mead

Ok so above – is my example.  To the left, is the book I mentioned from the author today.  It is an engaging cover and I like it… I want to know where she is going, or where she has went, or who has taken her…. the only thing that would bother me here is if the girl in the book has long flowing BLOND hair, or if her hair is short, unlike the cover.  To the right, is Vampire Academy.  Nothing against the book… but this girl on the cover makes me think of an older girl than the protagonist in the book.

There have been books I have read that the character inside the book is NOTHING like the cover picture and I can not even tell you how bat sh** crazy that makes me.  I seriously flip from the cover to the page I am reading to the cover again… if the girl (or boy) on the cover is not the one described in the book, then who is she or he?

 

There is one instance that comes to mind from a few years back where the cover actually caused an all out battle.  Seriously… anyone remember LIAR?

 

LIAR Justine Larbalestier Sheila Book Journey Black White

 

LIAR is the story of Micah who is well… a liar.  And I will say she is!  Or at least the people who made the cover are, because Micah, is an African-American girl… not at all the one in the cover.  There is a HUGE story behind this cover and there was a refusal by bloggers to review the book as they were all so upset that the publishing company went with a white girl on the cover.  Seriously…. this is a whole other story so Google it someday, but the ending result of this battle was:

 

 

LIAR Justine Larbalestier Sheila Book Journey Black White

Yup.  Seriously amazing… and all of this could have been avoided.

I really prefer non-face covers.  Give me a lake setting, a boat, abandoned car, a road, a house, even people way in the background so you can not really make them out… you name it… I can pretty much work with it… all of these lead me into the story…

 

“Who lives there?”

 

“Where are they going?”

 

What is going to happen?

 

What are your thoughts on book covers?  Preferences? Do you mind faces on book covers?  How do you feel when the cover does not match the story?