April Masterson and her hit YouTube Channel can tell you all about making melt-in-your-mouth lemon bars or how not to burn the edges of your brownies. She lives in a right-out-of-a-movie-style suburb with her husband, Elliot, and son, Bobby. All of this gives her the perfect wholesome, well-rounded media presence.

But when anonymous messages start being delivered to April… her perfect world begins to unravel. Someone is messing with April… someone who knows her deepest, darkest secrets. And the options of who it could be…. are many.

So yeah… I know. McFadden. Here we are again. I love her. And sometimes I don’t. This one falls in between. A lot was going on here…. while true to McFadden style… for me, it was too much going on. So many different ways this could have gone. In the end, I think I was so confused I didn’t care.

Was it me? Possibly. Maybe it was the wrong time for this one, and I was distracted. But not my fav.

Rated: 2.75ish out of 5
Read Author Before: yes
Read Author Again: yes because I do often enjoy her
Where Read: Back home after Vacation

Bookclub Worthy: I’m going to say no and probably for personal reasons – I want books for book club that make you think – that bring something to the discussion. Sure – you can talk about who did it and who we suspected – yes, there are some great ideas for food here with all the baking… but for myself…. I want more.