Sundays At Tiffany’s by James Patterson and Bookies Review

Jane Margaux is a girl who lives in a fairy tale world.  Her mother is the head of a powerful New York Theater and their home is filled with riches. 

Yet Jane is a very lonely little girl… her mother, the powerful and feared Vivian, makes time for her daughter once a week where on Sundays they go and admire the jewelery at Tiffany’s.

Jane has one friend who she can confide in and that would be Michael.  Michael listens to everything Jane says.  He hears and encourages her dreams and he shares with her the sorrows.  Michael is everything you would want in a best friend. 

Except…

Michael isn’t real.

And then on her 9th birthday, which is an epic disaster of its own, Michael tells Jane that he has to leave her.  He tells her while it hurts this day, when she wakes in the morning she will have forgotten him…. that’s the way it works…. that’s the way it has always worked.

But for Jane it doesn’t work that way… she misses her friend every day of her childhood and even into adult life.  Now producing her own play, a play about a young girl and her imaginary friend….. she is still under her mother’s thumb.  And then one day out of the corner of her eye she sees him….

could it be….

“Michael?”

Did you know Sundays At Tiffanys is also a Lifetime movie? I would like to see it.

My book club chose this book for our April read.  As you know from a recent post, I take no issue with Patterson and have found many of his books to be well written.  I have read him before when he wrote in this style and was impressed, his book Suzanne’s Diary For Nicholas was read in one sitting and left me in tears of joy and sorrow – all rolled into one. 

This was the first time I listened to a book club book rather than read it.  I was going to purchase the book but Kerri in our book club has picked up the audio at the library and was done listening to it and offered it to me.  I thought, why not?  What was funny was with the female narrator (who was very good!) I forgot who the author of the book was.  And it read on and the chapters flew by I remember thinking one day while I was driving through town, “wow this author has short chapters just like Patterson does.”  Then had to laugh – as I remembered, “Oh yeah… .this is Patterson.”

For most of the audio/book I adored the story.  I liked Jane, she starts out a little weak, but she is meant too – after all growing up in a household where you are constantly badgered by your mother on how to look, what to wear, what to eat…. yeah, that is going to leave a mark.  BUT – Jane is not all weak and you can see a flicker of her own personality start to slowly flicker and then burn brighter within her as the book goes on. 

I even really liked Michael – he is just a sweet guy and when the impossible happens, they find each other again, there is a sweet tone to the storyline – and I was still fine with the book…

Then somewhere along the line it hit me… when Jane was 9…. Michael wasn’t…. he was 32.  In fact he is 32 throughout the whole book being whatever he is (my book club tried to figure it out – an angel? A spirit? ) and never ages.  Now when they get back together Jane is very close to his age and its all cool – but I could not let go of the 32-year-old imaginary friend when Jane was a little girl.  I guess I just believed that when she was 9 so was he and that he just aged along with the rest of the world until they met again with adults.

Ok…. that whole scenario – put a creepy factor in my had on a scale of 1 – 10…. at about a 7. 

Overall – the book is a good read.  I did like the characters and I thought while the ending was all too neat and tied with a bow, it was still a respectable ending for a Patterson book that gave off a Nicholas Sparks vibe.

The 2011 WHERE Are You Reading Map has been update to include Sundays At Tiffany’s


Bookies Review

My book club met on Tuesday of this week to have dinner together and discuss this book.  I love it when we theme the foods to the book and Sundays at Tiffany’s is a dangerous book to do that with as the book is fulled with delights from Jane (and Michael’s) sweet tooth.   Thank you to Amy M’s hubby Paul for the delicious chocolate cake (this man can bake!) topped with truffles!  AND Laura brought an oreo ice cream cake as Jane’s favorite food is Oreos.  We also had a delicious chicken dish served on noodles or rice and Thai Chicken, a salad, and another chicken hot dish.  Amy served wine and lemonade, I brought cheese to go with the wine. 

I wanted to start out our discussion with everyone sharing if they had an imaginary friend when they were little… turns out, out of our group – I was the only one.  I was really surprised and through we would have a big discussion over this but it was just me.  her name was Julie…. I guess I was probably around that 8 or 9 age.  I remember walking with her at my grandmothers home in town, and I remember her in our home when I would talk to her about everything.  The group thought that maybe because I was an only child until I was 7 that may be why I had a “Julie” where they were all surrounded by siblings or other kids.  I found that very interesting as I had never thought about who has imaginary friends and who does not and why….

Over all the Bookies found the book to be a slightly higher than average read.  Only one other girl in our group found the Michael (32) and Jane (9) friendship to be creepy.  They looked at is as Jane’s replacement for the absence of her father in her life.  I can see that…. (ahhh the beauty of a book club discussion – you can things differently through others opinions!)  :D

We really did have fun discussing the book and that is one great thing about the Bookies, no matter what the book is like – we just enjoy getting together and always find a way to discuss the book and have fun.  We finished up our review with what our “can not pass up” foods are  and they were all over the board:  Chocolate cake, popcorn with cinnamon sugar and real butter on it, dill pickle sun flower seeds, toast with cinnamon and sugar and butter on it, cheese, anything chocolate….)

About Sheila (Book Journey)

Bookaholic * Audio Book Fan *Bike Rider *Rollerblader *Adventure Seeker *Want To Be Runner*Coffee lover *Fitness Fan * Movie junkie

Posted on April 15, 2011, in audio review, Book Review and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 32 Comments.

  1. That is creepy to think of a man being a 9 year old girl’s confidante because that is what a secret invisible friend is. Someone to talk to, to listen and never judge. Looking at it from a substitute father figure, I can somewhat see that but then, what girl confides everything and pals with her father. I like the idea better that he was her age and grew up just like her. That sits with me much better.

    Sundays at Tiffany’s sounds like a very good read. I’d love to see the movie version.

    Question, when she and Michael meet as adults, is he real?

    • What is interesting Shirley is there is a cover on line of a young boy and a young girl witting on a bench – but – and I missed this in the book, but my book club did not, it says early on in the book that he is 32.

      Its hard to explain your question without giving anything away – but yes, in the sense that others can finally see him too ;)

  2. They make dill pickle sunflower seeds?!?!? I have to get some for my sister.

  3. this one kind was pretty different for a Patterson read wasn’t it?? The cake looks so yummy! Have a great weekend!

  4. I “kind of” liked this book. It wasn’t bad and a quick read (here are my thoughts: http://manoflabook.com/wp/?p=763). However, does Patterson even writes these books or just lend his name for sales?

    • Thanks – I did not “not” like the book – in fact sailed through most of it before I creaped a bit :razz:

      The way I understand it – Patterson comes up with the ideas and starts the books and lets these other authors run with it and he assists and/or tweaks….

      off to look at your review ;)

  5. I have a copy of this that I haven’t read yet. I’ve lent it to two friends and they both liked it. So maybe I’ll give it a try. I’ve been hesitant to read the co-authored Patterson books … I’ve seen more than a few negative comments on them.

    • I know there are negative comments out there on Patterson… but I like his books and if authors connect to his name I say awesome for them to get a great connection and an opportunity to publish :D

      I hope you like the book!

  6. I have read the book and really enjoyed. I also saw the Lifetime movie. From I remembered of the book, the movie was a bit different. The one thing the movie did was Michael was 9 when Jane was 9, which made it much more believable for him to be an imaginary friend. I enjoyed both reading the book and seeing the movie.

  7. I loved the movie for this book. Michael was SO cute. But I haven’t read the book.

  8. I had a whole host of imaginary friends as a child! Christine and Peggy are the ones I remember best, but there were many more, as well as an imaginary horse and a rabbit. My mom would even sometimes set a place at the dinner table for Christine and/or Peggy. :)

    Everything you said you disliked about the book is what I didn’t like about it – the creepy factor of the age difference, the tied-up-neatly ending, and the Nicholas Sparks vibe.

  9. I have the book but haven’t read it yet, but I watched the movie and thought it was adorable!! The food looks delicious!

  10. I would not have been able to get past that age difference either – that is exactly the kind of thing I focus on lol.

    My brother had an imaginary friend too when he was a kid – Louie. My brother was about 4 or 5 when he Louie was around. I remember the exact moment when he let go of Louie, we were on vacation, and as we were driving away, my brother said we left Louie behind. And Louie never caught up to us I guess, because Devin never talked about him again.

  11. I did enjoy this book, even the more cheesy moment as i’m a sucker for romance but i was a bit disappointed. this novel has made it onto a lot of ‘books to read before you die’ lists and I dont think it quite deserves it…. would you agree?
    New to the world of blogs, take a look at the one I just started!

  12. This is a great review! I have this in my tbr list and can’t wait to read it! LOL!

  13. I saw the movie a while back and really enjoyed it I will have to look for the book to read it sounds like the book was as good

  14. I thought the book was creepy for that same reason. I also thought the writing was a bit cheesy.

    • I listened to it on audio so I may have missed the cheesiness :razz:

      I am glad that someone agrees with me on the creep factor…. my book club thought I had a dirty mind since they had not thought about the age difference….

  15. stacybuckeye

    I was totally creeped out by the age differnce when I read this too.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,815 other followers